24/05/2013 :: Native MP4/H.264 playback AND new software licensing (ELS) now included in latest Beta 11.1.L. Please see the announcement
Welcome, Guest
Username Password: Remember me

TOPIC: [Solved] Has anyone been able to edit at all?

Re: Has anyone been able to edit at all? 2 years, 5 months ago #502

That information hasn't been there for the past MONTH when I was waiting in anticipation of this. Had I known it didn't support anything in my current workflow, I wouldn't have bothered.

So I can import (without extra fees)

Images (DPX says it should work..)
P2 (Panasonic only)
DVCProHD (Panasonic only)
IMX (SD)
DV (SD)
HDV (consumer standard)
Mpeg2 I-Frame (Matrox codec didn't work)
Uncompressed... yea RIGHT.

Ok, I'll fire it up again, and try to import an IMX, a PNG sequence, and a bit of uncompressed just to see what it does.

[result]

IMX (unsupported format)
DV (import error content unknown)
Uncompressed (import error)
PNG Sequence (import error)
DPX sequence (format unlicensed)
HDV (not see as m2t, changed to .mpg... No Material error)


That's about all I have. (Back to Avid for me)

Re: Has anyone been able to edit at all? 2 years, 5 months ago #508

Sorry to be a pain - but I'm pretty sure that information has been there since the first announcements on the EditShare Specifications Page. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, but I have known about the "extra fees" for a while now, and all I have to go off is the website.

We have only been testing the system since this morning, but we have had good results bringing in a number of files. When we drag in a Canon 5D clip for example, we are given the option to "Create a Link" (i.e. link to the original file), "Copy Local" or "Transcode".

The transcoding options are as follows:

  • DVCPRO100 (Quicktime Wrapper)
  • AVCIntra100 (Quicktime Wrapper)
  • DVCPRO 100 (MXF Wrapper)
  • DVCPRO100 (AVI Wrapper)
  • Lightworks RLE (AVI Wrapper)
  • Uncompressed (AVI Wrapper)
  • RGB32 (AVI Wrapper)
  • MPEG I-Frame HD (AVI Wrapper - with custom Bit Rate Options)


We tested bringing in image sequences, various Quicktimes, DV footage, MXFs, AVIs, DVCPRO HD Footage and HDV footage so far, and haven't had any issues. We're running Lightworks on a MacPro runnings Parallels Desktop.

What we have found (so far), is that you can basically bring in any Quicktime Format that plays properly in Quicktime Player.

Make sure you have the latest version of Quicktime Installed, and that your Windows Operating System is up-to-date.

That's a very interesting point about the DPX sequences! We are going to do some DPX sequence import tests today - we'll let you know how we go!

We are also going to do some tests bringing in Avid DNxHD files (within a Quicktime Wrapper) to see how that works.

We're obviously going to stick with Avid and FCP for the foreseeable future (especially as we're all Mac's at our facility), but we'll keep playing with Lightworks, as it does look kind of intriguing!

Happy Cutting!

Best Regards, Chris!

Re: Has anyone been able to edit at all? 2 years, 5 months ago #558

Quicktime was installed this morning. And I just ran MS Update and admittedly there were a TON of updates that needed to be applied. However, after having done that and rebooting, my issues remain.

I also notice that on trying to "close the room" it goes into a saving project database and hangs there. Might be the same thing that's causing my media offline error, but I can't find the issue.

Re: Has anyone been able to edit at all? 2 years, 5 months ago #574

We have done some more tests...

DV-PAL (Quicktime Wrapper) = Works
DVCPRO50 (Quicktime Wrapper) = Works
HDV 1080i (Quicktime Wrapper) = Works
RED R3D = Content Unknown
JPEG Image Sequence = Works
DPX Image Sequence = Format Unlicensed

As we keep playing, we will keep you posted on the results...

Re: Has anyone been able to edit at all? 2 years, 5 months ago #579

  • dermot
  • OFFLINE
  • Senior Boarder
  • Posts: 45
No issues here with anything as far as actualy getting the media in, but i am trying to sus out how it does color Xform on linking & capturing....

more tests needed

but yes to the orignal question, i cut a sequence today.... first one on Lightworks since 1999

Re: Has anyone been able to edit at all? 2 years, 5 months ago #588

  • djordan2
  • OFFLINE
  • Fresh Boarder
  • Posts: 7
If you can get over the ui issues and have media in the right codec, it seems to work for both editing and export to certain formats.
Time to create page: 1.26 seconds
Copyright EditShare EMEA 2013